Find a back issue

photography by Brandon Thibodeaux

What Troubles Me About the Legend of Chris Kyle

If our record website traffic numbers of the past week are any indication, most of you are well aware that our own Michael J. Mooney has written an article in the April issue of D Magazine about former Navy SEAL sniper Chris Kyle, who was senselessly killed in February by a fellow veteran whom he was trying to help recover from mental illness. You should read the whole thing.

I’ve no doubt that Kyle’s wartime heroics saved many American lives, and that he and men like him deserve our thanks for the sacrifices they made. But in considering his legacy, I can’t get past that story (first written by Mike on this blog, then fleshed out at the beginning of his magazine piece) about Kyle killing two would-be carjackers at a gas station along Highway 67 south of Dallas.

Leave aside for the moment the issue of whether this story is true. Let’s say that it all went down precisely as Kyle described it to Mike. I find that even more disturbing than if he’d just made the whole thing up. Here’s why:

1) No man, not even a decorated war hero, deserves the right to serve as judge, jury, and executioner. Had he turned over the keys to his truck, there’s a good chance there would have been no need for any deaths that night. If the two men were planning to murder him as well as steal his vehicle, they’d surely have shot Kyle on sight. They didn’t. Such criminals deserve punishment, but we shouldn’t applaud any individual for deciding for himself what that punishment should be.

2) But maybe I’ve got that first point wrong. Maybe Kyle was far more threatened by these men than I’m realizing, and so when he drew his weapon and fired, it truly was a case of justified self-defense. OK, fine. Why then should we be comfortable with local law enforcement and a mysterious figure at the other end of a phone line at the Department of Defense conspiring to sweep the matter under the rug, to the point where there’s apparently no evidence of the deaths of these men, no police report on the incident at all? And they do it just because “they didn’t want to drag a just-home, highly decorated veteran into a messy legal situation”? I don’t trust the local cops to decide who, on American soil in a non-combat situation, should have an unquestioned license to kill.

3) Perhaps you think I’m making too much out of those first two issues. You’ve got no problem whatsoever with Kyle’s actions that night or the cover-up that followed. How then do you feel about Kyle talking about it with a reporter? Our military goes to the trouble of muscling in on local authorities so that their guy can carry on with his day unfettered, and then Kyle discusses the matter openly? Talking to Mike he could have dropped just enough hints to allow some enterprising reporter to suss out exactly where this took place and which police department may have acted criminally in withholding public information and making dead bodies disappear. The very people who helped him out of his situation could themselves become exposed to prosecution because Kyle essentially ratted them out.

Any way I look at this, I’m bothered. I can’t seem to shrug it off.  (And I haven’t even mentioned the implications of what I consider the most likely scenario: that this didn’t happen at all, or is an extremely hyperbolic account.)

Mike writes that people will be telling stories about Kyle generations from now, stories that may get embellished over time to the point where we’re no longer sure what’s true, and that “it may not matter too much, because people believe in legends for all their own reasons.”

I don’t understand those who would choose to believe and celebrate this particular legend about Chris Kyle. To me, it does nothing but besmirch what otherwise seems a legacy of laudable service to our nation.

173 comments on “What Troubles Me About the Legend of Chris Kyle

  1. “someone he can’t even begin to measure up to”

    All of us a superior to someone who makes up stories about killing people for the sake of his ego.
    Seriously, pretending you killed 30 people in Katrina means you are pretending you are a mass murderer for the sake of your ego.
    If you don’t feel superior to that person, you need to get your own head straight.

  2. “I worked in law enforcement for 25+ years and served in the Army”

    You didn’t work a single day in any law enforcement agency that fails to record multiple shootings or lets people leave the scene based on what their name is.

  3. “Now we come to the tricky part. Do we press charges?”

    You can’t press charges. All of the police departments that could have jurisdiction over that area said it is a lie, no such shooting took place.

  4. Sounds like your pissed you didnt get the story to write about. If two guys had gun on me, your dam straight i would fire back. Media is alot to blame on how people act. Look at all the school shootings. If the first one was never televised you would have far less school shootings. Get a life and write about something good instead of trashing people.

  5. No one is extending sympathy for the two dead criminals, if they existed at all. Whether they deserved to die or not is not at issue. The question, as others have so clearly stated, is whether such a double killing can simply be swept under the rug. Chris Kyle’s military service, heroic as it was, is not an excuse to kill two people and then make it disappear. The incident must still be investigated as a homicide. If the circumstances hold it up as justifiable, fine, but Chris Kyle was not 007 with a license to kill. In this case, it sounds more likely that he was either a pathological liar or was himself suffering from mental illness. I can’t imagine someone killing 160 people in wartime, being wounded twice, and being in 6 IED attacks, without being affected by it in some way.

  6. And then there’s his story that he was a professional bronco rider who had to quit after a bronco fell on top of him in the chute, dislocating his shoulder, breaking his ribs and damaging his wrists so badly that he had pins put in both of them. He even had to be helicoptered to the hospital. He should have scars on his wrists. I don’t see any. Do you?

    When asked in his deposition what his job was during the period when he was supposedly a pro bronc rider, Kyle said that he was a ranch hand.

    I suspect that Kyle is a world-class liar. I doubt if we’ll be telling stories about him in five years. Maybe we’ll be talking about the astonishing credulity of Fox News and the American public.

  7. Kyle claims he was awarded two silver stars. In a photo of him receiving a JINSA award in 2005, I don’t see him wearing that insignia so he must not have had one then. He’s also not listed in, but that website may not be a complete listing. I see Michael Monsoor’s Medal of Honor, but don’t see silver stars for Monsoor–and he reportedly had them.

    Probably wouldn’t hurt to double check that Kyle was actually awarded the medals he claimed.

  8. Lord. I just read the part in AS where he talks about his post-accident wrist pins. He says they stuck out a few inches on either side and once when he was driving one of them was banging into the signal indicator so he broke the pin off at the skin level. Uh-huh. That’s the last we hear about that until later in the book when he says that a Navy physical “revealed” that he had pins in his arm. I guess he’s talking about these wrist pins that stick out a few inches because he doesn’t tell us about any others.

    Everything Kyle says is a lie, including “and” and “the.”

  9. Jason,
    You are a full blown idiot for giving out advice on how to handle a carjacking. You are way outside in area you have expertise in. You are entitled to you opinion but when your advice is reckless and could cause considerable harm to anyone foolish enough to take your advice you should be called out.

    The story is made up most likely by another full blown idiot working with you. It is obvious the burden of proof for publishing here is very low or non-existent. There is no evidence Chris ever said this other than a claim of one wane be journalist. The Super Dome incident is hearsay as well. A clever way of bumping up web hits.

  10. WRONG…WRONG…WRONG. Ratfinks deserved execution…the gene pool is better without them!

  11. Oh brother…if you get carjacked, you may wish to defend yourself, or, perhaps you’d prefer to die yourself

  12. How To Stop A Divorce And Save Your Marriage?

    My name is Mellisa Lopez .i live in NY, USA , am a woman who love and cherish my husband more than any other thing you can imagine on earth continent. My husband was so lovely and caring after 3years of marriage he was seriously ill and the doctor confirm and said he has a kidney infection that he needed a kidney donor, that was how I start searching for a good Samaritan who can help,doctor has given me a periodic hour that he will live just 26hours left, that was how I ask the doctor if I can be of help to my husband that was how he carried out the text,the confirming was successful, I was now having this taught that since 3 years now we got married I have not be able to get pregnant can I be able to get bring again? That was the question I ask the doctor, he never answer his response was did you want to lost your husband? I immediately reply no I can’t afford to loose him. After the operation my husband came back to live and was healthy I was also ok with the instruction given to me by the doctor, after 3months my husband came home with another lady telling me, that is our new wife that will give us kids and take care of us, that was how I was confused and started crying all day, that was how my husband ran away with his new wife cluaralle. Since then I was confuse don’t no what to do that was how I went back to the doctor and tell him everything, he told me that, this is not just an ordinary it must be a spiritual problem that was how he gave me this email ( ) that I should tell her all my problem that she can help that was how i contacted her and I do as instructed. After 3days and I have done what she ask me to do, my husband start searching for me and went back to the doctor, that was how we well settle she also told me not to worry that I will get pregnant, this month making it the fifth Month I contacted her am now 3months pregnant. These great spell cater is a great man, if you are any kind of problem you can contact him here on his email ( ) website address:

  13. Well I’ll quote Chris here:
    “Despite what your momma told you, violence does solve problems.”

    My question would why did these two low life’s have a god damn right to hold Chris up at Gun Point demanding his money & his truck in the first place?

    Only a do Gooder Lilly live red soft cock would argue any other way!

    Society spends far to much money & time trying to readjust these criminals so they can be released back into society to repeat their acts of crime. Eye for an eye, tooth for an tooth!

    I hope one day, you & your family are held up by gun point & let’s see how understanding you are at the end of the day.

    My other question would be why did Chris have to find a need to lie in the first place?
    He was already a War Hero, a Legend & one of the most decorated Veterans around, there was no need to lie at all.
    You doogooders are the reason thousands of innocent people died in the Twin Towers. You traitors questioned the American Way of life & let those scumbags into your country to commit on of the most horrific crimes of all time.
    I suppose you think that incident was a conspiracy & no one died at all. Just a bit of showmanship to get everyone onside so they could invade the Middle ESt????
    Why don’t you Dogooder Losers take a friendly visit over there & catch up with you friendly ISIL Team & see how loving these guys are towards you all.
    Christ I can’t stand losers like you taking the sides of Criminals.
    Traitors the lot of you all.
    Rant over.

  14. Face it he, PO Kyle, was top secret. get over it.

    BTW Kyle was given 2 purple hearts. Anyone with any info on the injuries wounds?

  15. Looks like the writer is not a war veteran.A soldier who has fired a gun in battle,has automatic instincts,to fire when danger approaches even in civil life.

    So allow Chris Kyle to be the hero,THE LEGEND.

  16. Hi, i am Natasha, and i am sharing my testimony, with the whole world, on how i got my ex husband back within 48 hours, by the help of the superb Dr. Brave. After just 2 years in marriage with my husband kyle. He divorced me and got separated from me and our little son Shaw. He left home to another lady. I did all i could to get him back, but they all proved abortive. Until one faithful day, an old friend of mine Sarah, told me about Dr Brave, who helped her in a similar issue. At first, i doubted it, but later on, i decided to give it a try. When i did, he helped me cast a re-union lover’s spell. And within 48 hours, my husband came back, pleading and apologizing to me. And right now, we are very happy together, with abundant love, joy and riches. You too can contact this amazing spell caster right now, on any issue that you are having on his or you can contact him through his website
    Thank you so much great one, i won’t forget your amazing works.
    Love and regards’

    Natasha Johnson
    London, UK.

  17. get a clue, this guy served for our country for 4 tours in iraq, two men holding a gun at him demanding his truck, who do they think they are…he has a right to defend himself after what he has been through…i would say he is a hero as well for getting those two scumbags off the street.

  18. Marylou, What about the 25 Negro looters he shot in NO? That put a quick stop to the looting.
    BTW Did Kyle have PTSD also? Was Kyle or Eddie Ray receiving a monthly PTSD check? what will happen to the check? will Eddie still get his check in prison? Will Kyles widow Taya get the check for Chris?

  19. He lied about the supposed car jacking and the so-called Ventura knockout. What the hell else do you think he is lying about? I don’t like the fact that he wrote a book about what he did in Iraq. To me it is something that soldiers should keep to themselves. I don’t think Americans need to hear about his kills.

  20. The government is not going to cover for a war hero like that. Researchers have tried for some time now to find evidence of this carjacking and it does not exist. Nor did he punch Ventura as he claims. Unless you have not been reading these postings here there are cops, one from Texas posting here that says all checks with Texas law enforcement authorities show the incident did not happen.

    Another thing I will not worship people who serve in the military and kill civilians around the world. Chris Kyle bragged about what he did as though it was a trip to Disney land. The U.S. Military is a murder machine that has killed millions of civilians around the world without cause, not some half dead, man on kidney dialysis in a cave somewhere. America supports murder and its citizens worship at the feet of cold blooded killers.